An astronaut falls out of the sky, two vloggers wander into a river of garbage, a flock of birds decides it's had enough of people, and an ex-cop with a thing about shoplifters gets a text in ALL CAPS telling him to fly to Hong Kong. Praxeus is Doctor Who's microplastics story, with South Africa standing in for three continents, and it aired just weeks before a real pandemic shut down the world. It started life as an Auton script, and by the time it reached the screen it was, in Chris's words, very highly processed: Doctor Who as a zip file, which you have to unpack in your head afterward to find out whether there was a story in there. So we unpack it. We've got a guest cast with one note each, a villain revealed two-thirds of the way through who leaves as a puff of dust, a hazmat squad with stormtrooper aim, and Ryan being cool for maybe the first time ever. Is this a worthy swing at the most Doctor Who subject there is? Or is it the one piece of plastic on Earth that doesn't stick around?
Watch on YouTube · Listen on Spotify · Apple Podcasts
True Companions on YouTube got this episode six days early, and they get a bonus conversation after it, Bigger on the Inside, every episode. Join the channel and the next one is yours too.
Plot Summary
A plague that feeds on plastic finds the one planet where there's plastic in everybody.
Notable for:
Written by Pete McTighe, who wrote Kerblam! the season before, with showrunner Chris Chibnall; McTighe has said the story was originally meant to bring back the Autons, and the Doctor still name-checks them when she sees what the plastic is doing to the birds
An early draft was called Hush: Jake was still a serving policeman, Suki's colleague was called Sanya, the Doctor was called to a beached submarine at a port, and the infected became "plastic people" who turned out to be clones (DWM 570 supplement)
Shot in South Africa in the first production block of the series, alongside Spyfall: Stellenbosch stood in for the Peruvian beach, Kogel Bay for Madagascar and Cape Town for Hong Kong, with the Hong Kong warehouse at Mamhilad Park Estate in Pontypool and the supermarket at Cardiff Food Centre
Broadcast on BBC One on 2 February 2020 to 3.97 million overnight (the fourth most-watched programme of the day) and 5.22 million consolidated, with an Appreciation Index of 78
Aired as the real coronavirus was beginning to spread, so fans drew parallels between Praxeus and the pandemic; the episode was written and filmed long before anyone had heard of COVID-19
Gabriela Toloi (Jamila) was the first Brazilian actress in a Doctor Who television story; she and Joana Borja's Gabriela speak Portuguese on screen, and the shooting script names the Peruvian hospital Cusco Hospital
The last episode Millennium FX worked on; the hazmat alien under the mask is Jamie McKee, uncredited, and Suki's lab computer runs Windows 7
Picks up directly from Fugitive of the Judoon: the team is chasing the three distress signals the TARDIS received, and keeps in touch with the comm dots introduced in The Tsuranga Conundrum
The TARDIS materialises around Jake to save him, as it did in The Parting of the Ways, Let's Kill Hitler and Dinosaurs on a Spaceship; Jake and astronaut Adam Lang are a married couple on the rocks, and Graham calls Jake Inspector Morse
Reviews were middling: 71% on Rotten Tomatoes, a B+ from The A.V. Club and four stars from The Independent against two from Radio Times and The Telegraph; the consensus called it a step back from Fugitive of the Judoon but a fun return to basics. Rumours that the Sea Devils would return proved false

Pete commentary:
Praxeus is a strange mess. It feels like one long trail of exposition, never firmly grabbing hold of any of the ideas it puts forward. It’s an environmental cautionary tale, clearly, coming just three episodes after the similarly themed Orphan 55. Praxeus is the better of the two, but it’s the lowest of bars to clear.
It's also super unmemorable. There's almost no variety in the pacing; it just goes on and on at the same clip. I watched it a week or so ago and had to work to remember what actually happens.
Some weird character moments that are dumb for no reason. Aramu is supposed to be keeping an eye on the birds, and with the eeriness already well established, he wanders away from the building and gets killed by them. Then nobody seems to care that he's dead.
That's a pattern here. Several people die who clearly have friends who love them, and everyone moves on really, really quickly. Jamila dies in the first act, and by the end Gabriela is happy-go-lucky, starting a friendship with the gang and suggesting they can all vlog about it. Her friend just died.

Credit where it's due: they put the big TARDIS crew to work by splitting them up, and it flips the usual Doctor Who setup. Normally the Doctor and the companions are the ones asking what's going on and what world they're on. Here the guest characters do the asking, and Ryan, Graham and Yaz are the investigators who seem to be on top of things, bringing the guests into the story (Gabriela finding Ryan; Graham and Yaz coming at Jake as he hammers on the door). A neat subversion of the formula.
The trouble is we never get enough time with any of the guests to like them. Jake gets a bit of backstory, but it's a strange one: Joyce telling him it isn't working out, the shoplifter he was maybe a little rough with, and honestly I'm a bit on his side. Are we supposed to like Jake? Same with Gabriela and Jamila: one scene each. We usually credit Doctor Who for being economical in its storytelling, but this is too economical. We don't care about these people, as hard as the script tries.
The best scene for caring about anyone is early: Ryan and Gabriela. It's honestly one of the better first acts Ryan has had. He's on top of things, with the right mix of gentleness and urgency, and you believe a friendship forming fast. His "I've done a fair bit of travelling myself" line in Peru is great.
It's a decent one for Yaz too. She gets to show the Doctor her bravery, staying behind to work things out with danger around, and she ends up following Suki's teleport with Gabriela to the alien ship on the floor of the Indian Ocean. Interesting ideas, instantly forgettable.

The threat never comes into focus. Killer birds, and then the plastic growth that crystallizes people and turns them to dust. It should be far more disturbing than it is. There's a stolidness to the direction that never lands any of it on a visceral level, and there's plenty of material here that should.
Which is it, the virus or the birds? Both is too much for 45 minutes. I know you don't want to just remake The Andromeda Strain, but an alien virus is terrifying all on its own: everyone who has it on them is a ticking time bomb. That's plenty. The birds never make sense. Are they a side effect of the virus, or something the aliens control? And why kill everyone anyway? Because the aliens are callous, I guess.
Suki. There are already too many people in the TARDIS crew, plus the guests, so there's no time to understand her or care about her. The Doctor works out she's an alien scientist whose own people have the disease (her species is never named, as far as I can tell) and snips her out of the story. There's some decent dialogue in the ship at the end that finally explains what's going on, but by then the pacing has exhausted you. You want to care, and it whizzes by.
What the Whittaker era does really well, and this one too: scale. The hopping between countries, the datelines (Madagascar, Hong Kong, Peru) and the South African location work make the show feel very big. I like that. (Stellenbosch for Peru, Kogel Bay for Madagascar, Cape Town for Hong Kong.)
The hospital in Peru is a cool Walking Dead sequence, though it's never clear why it's been abandoned. One infected guy and everybody leaves? Think of an American hospital: even with a general evacuation, where are the people in hazmat suits? Maybe they're still working out the appropriate response. Sort of believable. Still.
The comm dots. The gang talking to each other across the world would come in very handy in a lot of Doctor Who episodes. (They debuted in The Tsuranga Conundrum, so they're at least established.) It's the remote-control TARDIS problem: either have a rule against it or don't do it, because once you've done it, why not every time?

The worst shots in the universe. The hazmat aliens fire at Graham, Yaz, Jake and Adam in the warehouse and hit nothing. Every action franchise has to fudge this, but the Whittaker era is replete with it and never writes or blocks around it. You can do a passable action scene where the misses are believable, with the right blocking and moment-by-moment direction. If you can't, don't bother.
Jamie Magnus Stone: this was his first series on the show. Spyfall Part One, Praxeus, Ascension of the Cybermen and The Timeless Children here; The Halloween Apocalypse, War of the Sontarans and Village of the Angels in Flux; then The Power of the Doctor. Middling, all of it, except Village of the Angels, the one that rises above. Competent, no outstanding work, and one of the chief violators on the bad-aim scenes. In fairness, the Whittaker era suffered from lousy writing, and Praxeus is a case in point.
Related: the birds get into the lab in Madagascar, super violent, having just made short work of Aramu, and the Doctor and the whole gang get back to the TARDIS without a scratch on them. Silly.
In the end, with all the plastic and the globe-trotting and the roll call of characters, it feels one part documentary. The show has always had an educational streak, and it does environmental stories, but it shouldn't feel like a documentary, and on some level this one does.
What did Pete's family think?
Watched it with Grace. "Oh yeah, it was fine." Then she tried to show she liked it, then: "That was just okay." She was being nice. Grace is generally positive and she completely checked herself, so she didn't love it.
Four Questions to Doomsday - Pete
Why did the Randomizer take us here? From City of Death, the really, really good, to the really, really bad: there's that. An infectious alien presence slowly taking over things on Earth, in a foreign country, is straight out of The Masque of Mandragora. Survival is in there too: an alien race trying to survive, here by finding a cure for Praxeus. Everyone is always trying to use Earth, whether it's the Mandragora Helix, Scaroth or these aliens and their virus. And Masque had its gay theme in Giuliano and Marco, a little more than subtext; here it's full on, and yet somehow Masque is the gayer story. There's gayness here without any gay culture or camp. Maybe that's progress. Let's go with progress.
What if the evil plot had succeeded? The aliens aren't really out to conquer Earth; they're here to let Praxeus run its course and develop a cure for themselves, which is devastating for Earth all the same. If they succeed, they get their cure and leave, and Earth becomes a Praxeus world. Tons of people die. The Doctor and her companions probably die too; honestly they should have, in the lab, if those birds were as lethal as they'd just been with Aramu. So let's say the birds kick some ass in Madagascar. Yaz is alone in the ship; Suki takes her prisoner, maybe infects her, gets the cure from the Doctor's work and doesn't care what happens to her. The Doctor is the only one who makes it back to the TARDIS, and she's dying. She tracks Yaz and gets the TARDIS into the ship anyway; Yaz takes over and tries to nurse her back to health, and the Doctor regenerates. Into Tennant, let's say. Tennant and Yaz go after the aliens for the cure while Earth starts to succumb. The Doctor eventually gets it, but Earth is a very wounded world. And Yaz has very weird feelings now: she probably still loves the Doctor, but she's not quite as into him now that he's a man.
Where's the Clara splinter? It's never explained how Adam got a message out to Jake once the aliens had him in the Hong Kong warehouse. The Clara splinter made sure there was a burner phone lying around for him to find.
Dalek, Ogron, Professor Hayter, Viscount Banger, Fixed Point in Time, Lady Cassandra, or Zarbi? One of the lower ones. I hate to do it, and I know I'm harsh on the Whittaker era. But it does the worst thing Doctor Who can do: I just don't care. The only neat moments are Ryan's, early on. I don't really like any of the guest characters; Jake a little, but Adam is bland, Suki is forgettable and bland, Gabriela is stock. It never spends enough time with any one of them to get to know them, care about them or enjoy what they're doing. It isn't a Lady Cassandra, because the plot isn't paper thin. It's super plot-heavy; I just don't care about any of it. It commits too many sins, and there's never anything to grab onto. Cassandra-Ogron hybrid.

Chris commentary:
The thing about Praxeus is … it's a strange bird. <rim shot> I was barely clinging on to caring about this way-too-large guest cast, and kind of scoffed and rolled my eyes at a lot of the choices throughout. The lack of a specific villain for nearly all the runtime really stood out to me, because when I watched I was literally on a fiction-writing retreat when I was watching it, one that was drilling home the message that you don't really have a story until you introduce the antagonist – in part because they need plenty of space to breathe, to become interestingly complex. (see City of Death, Scarlioni). Suki seems an unfortunately perfect negative example of that. Revealed more than ⅔ of the way through and we don’t really care about her people, who are actually in a tough position that the story doesn’t care about enough. This is its original sin.
But the antagonist rule begs to be broken, so I appreciate the effort, and a tightly-wrapped ending (Praxeus is never stronger than in its conclusion) made more sense of those choices. So in respooling the story backwards in my head, they became more real, Jake and Adam's relationship took more shape, and the whole premise became more solid. It's almost like Praxeus is delivered as a virus in a ZIP file – you have to do almost all of the unpacking work afterwards.
Is that a good thing? I can see the temptation to do Doctor Who as ZIP files, because you always have more ideas than money to make them a reality, so you want to pack as many into the space available. Moffat certainly gave into that temptation in overly-compressed stories like Nightmare in Silver.
Lingering in my brain longer than expected, though – McTighe stories tend to do that for me, love 'em or hate 'em (and I've done both). While I'm never going to call this one of the greatest Doctor Who stories ever made, or even one of the greatest Jodie Whittakers, it seems like decent mid-level Who.
I don't hate the environmental message, like I did with Orphan 55, because in this case it's a specific one – just one word, Benjamin – microplastics. A real threat no one can deny, a lot of science to impart in a Hartnell-esque way (eg. the five major gyres on Earth), and given the Auton connection (how I wish they'd done that!) a real Doctor Who topic. The Pertwee era would look at modern Who askance if it didn't cover our plague of microplastics at all. So, yay microplastic stories! Even if the topic does start to seem a bit overdone, now I'm coming back to Praxeus after the War Between the Land and the Sea … I'd still be down for an Auton take.

I thought I'd be more irked in retrospect by the ADHD location changes and the TARDIS team scattered to the winds from the start, but this seems more forgivable than making the large cast so annoyingly one-note. If you're going to make them one note, make it a good one note.
Prime example of this is Gabriela. I get it, you promote your vlog, but "you haven't heard of us?" was kind of falling flat in 2020, let alone 2026, when there's just too much content for a presumption that any one of us has seen the same thing. (I don't think we'd ever say, no matter how many followers PTO gets, "you haven't heard of us?") It makes her look like a narcissist, which is a terrible clash with any attempt to make her sympathetic.
Likewise, what is there to love about Jake until after he rescues Adam? You have to get it from the actor's charm, because it's not there on the page. He's an ex-cop! Who assaults shoplifters! And takes it for granted that "Adam" from a random number is who he says he is! Dumb and dumber.
Still, at least he survives; a nice reversal of expectations from what happens to the "let me sacrifice myself" character in regular Who.
We should mention the eerie coincidence of this airing just as COVID was getting started. Couldn't the Doctor have stuffed some mRNA vaccine from a year in the future in that airborne Praxeus-killing virus, and save us all a lot of trouble?
Four Questions to Doomsday - Chris
Why did the Randomizer take us here? To make us compare the incredibly creative constrictions that gave us the location-shot City of Death with the location-shot of Praxeus, which had seemingly unlimited Hollywood budget by comparison and yet suffered from being … over-made. Plus we're a pair of vloggers who've been on this random adventure for around 5 years …
What if the evil plot had succeeded? Her cure works when she's injecting it into herself, instead of blowing her to dust. Then her people are cured, yay, and we still have to deal with Praxeus on this planet. Though maybe if they just hung around a month, the Doctor could also throw in a COVID-19 cure, some sort of futuristic version of the mRNA vaccine, and save us all a lot of trouble on this pandemic.
Where's the Clara splinter? It's tempting to say that because Clara might have a bit of PTSD about birds, given Face the Raven, she might not want to get too close to the action on this. But there is so much for her to do here. There's a lot of moving around, a lot of transportation to be done, dropping people off at the right place who aren't using TARDIS travel. Clara's an EMT who's chronically bad at charging her phone.
Dalek, Ogron, Professor Hayter, Viscount Banger, Fixed Point in Time, Lady Cassandra, or Zarbi? A clear-cut Professor Hayter. I didn't hate it as much at the end as when I was walking through it, because I was unpacking it in my head. And we did learn something: the number of gyres of plastic trash floating around the oceans. There are five. Well done, Doctor Who, you taught me that. It tried a lot of things. It just didn't quite hit, and might have done with Autons.



I think this is the first time I have seen Chris completely stumped by a whomoji. Thank you so much for taking it. Here is another, if you're still short on them:
☄️🎭🦎💀🤖🔥
—
—
—
Answer: The Visitation